Pope's Environmental Message and Notre Dame's Coal Conundrum
In 2015, Pope Francis delivered a forceful call to action on climate change, urging both Catholics and non-Catholics to address environmental issues. This appeal resonated with many institutions, including the University of Notre Dame, which took steps to reduce its reliance on fossil fuels. However, the university's actions in Alabama have come under scrutiny.
Despite its public commitment to sustainability, Notre Dame maintains a mineral rights lease with Warrior Met Coal in Alabama. The lease, dating back to 2013, permits coal mining on land owned by the university. This arrangement appears to conflict with Notre Dame's environmental goals, including its pledge for carbon neutrality by 2050.
A university spokesperson confirmed Notre Dame's ownership of the Alabama mineral rights but did not share details about the agreement or how it aligns with the university's green initiatives. The spokesperson noted the rights were a donation meant to further academic and research missions.
Emily Grubert, a former U.S. Department of Energy official and current Notre Dame faculty member, stated that accepting the mineral rights does not absolve the institution from considering their environmental impact. She emphasized that ignoring such investments seems inconsistent with Notre Dame's moral clarity.
The Pope's Directive on Climate Change
Pope Francis' 2015 encyclical, "Laudato Si'," urged a global move away from fossil fuels, pinpointing coal as particularly harmful. The document inspired many Catholic institutions, including Notre Dame, to adopt more sustainable policies.
The university announced plans to eliminate coal use on campus by 2020 and ultimately achieved this goal ahead of schedule. Notre Dame aims to reach complete carbon neutrality by 2050 through multiple initiatives, including geothermal and solar energy.
Notre Dame's Alabama Connection
Notre Dame's lease with Warrior Met identifies the university as the primary mineral rights holder for land central to the coal company's Blue Creek expansion. The project would increase Warrior Met's production capacity significantly, potentially extending its operations for another 50 years.
In addition to Notre Dame, several other private entities hold minority stakes in the land. The project awaits various regulatory approvals, including from the Bureau of Land Management, for the extraction of public coal reserves.
Warrior Met's expansion has attracted public investment and is expected to garner substantial financial support, although the company has faced criticism for its safety and environmental practices.
Navigating Moral and Environmental Obligations
Pope Francis highlighted the urgent need for a transition away from coal. Consequently, institutions like Notre Dame face questions about balancing financial benefits with ethical responsibilities. Grubert suggests that Notre Dame should be transparent about its investments and use its influence responsibly.
Longwall mining, used in Alabama, has historically caused environmental and safety issues. Local residents have raised concerns about methane emissions and land subsidence, with incidents like a fatal 2024 explosion underscoring the risks.
Grubert argues for increased transparency in institutional investments and believes that Notre Dame, with its resources and commitments, should take these issues more seriously. She calls for awareness in wielding institutional power to effect positive change in the industry.
Read more at Inside Climate News
