Trump's AI Action Plan Faces Criticism Over China Chip Sales Reversal

The Facts -

  • Trump's AI plan seeks US tech supremacy, stirring China tensions.
  • Nvidia's chip sales to China spark US security concerns.
  • US-China tech rivalry shapes global AI and economic landscapes.


In a striking move, the Trump administration in late July unveiled its "America’s AI Action Plan," a comprehensive executive strategy aimed at advancing the country's AI capabilities and asserting technological dominance on a global scale. The strategy, with its bold tagline “Winning the Race,” underscores the initiative's primary goal of enhancing national security, particularly in the context of rising tensions with China. The complete plan can be accessed through this link.

Washington's decision to resume the sale of Nvidia's H20 graphics processing units to China has stirred controversy among national security experts. These chips, although not top-tier, are vital in AI inference technology. Despite initial export restrictions under Biden, Trump's administration opted to lift the ban following lobbying efforts from Nvidia's CEO, Jensen Huang. Huang argued that enabling China's reliance on US-designed chips would serve American interests better than restricting sales entirely.

This policy shift represents a notable departure from previous semiconductor control measures, sparking criticism as a "strategic misstep" by security experts and former officials. A letter to Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick criticized the move for potentially undermining US military and economic leadership in AI development. Some analysts suggest this decision might be a strategic gesture aimed at securing trade concessions from Beijing.

The evolution in export control policy suggests a reevaluation of the US's approach to competition with China. Initially, the American tech industry was united in its opposition to providing China with advanced AI hardware. However, this consensus is fracturing as sectors within the US tech industry seek growth opportunities beyond domestic markets.

Two key factors drive this pivot: the saturation of domestic hardware profitability and the unintended stimulation of Chinese innovation due to previous GPU restrictions. The US is now leveraging its technological advantage, not to restrict China's access, but to expand the global reach of its AI technology stack, including chips and data infrastructures, as outlined in the administration’s directive to promote US AI technology exports.

The Shift in US-China Dynamics

Historically, the US viewed China as a cooperative partner rather than a rival, promoting integration into the global economic order. This strategy began shifting with Trump's 2017 National Security Strategy, which reframed China's economic rise as a direct military threat, leading to tariffs and a crackdown on technology transfers, especially regarding firms like Huawei and ZTE.

Under President Biden, US-China tensions deepened, focusing less on individual firms and more on the broader supply chain vulnerabilities exposed by the Covid-19 pandemic. Initiatives like the CHIPS and Science Act signified a strategic pivot to bolster domestic semiconductor production and limit China's access to critical technologies.

European powers have mirrored this stance, with calls for "economic de-risking" in response to China's integration of military and commercial sectors. Such measures have highlighted the global shift towards protecting supply chains and technological sovereignty.

Silicon Valley's Influence

The recent redirection in policy underscores a growing tension between the Silicon Valley elite and national security interests within the White House. While both factions agree on the geopolitical importance of tech, they diverge on approaches to engaging China. Silicon Valley, led by figures like AI and crypto czar David Sacks, argues against restrictive export controls, citing missed economic opportunities.

This division is evident as tech companies advocate for a more inclusive global AI strategy, seeing the potential for American technology to dominate international markets. AMD CEO Lisa Su emphasized this at a Washington AI summit, stressing the importance of utilizing the American AI stack globally.

However, the challenge remains in balancing national security and commercial goals. As former Google executive Eric Schmidt noted in 2022, separating technologically from China must be measured to avoid detriment to US interests, recognizing the mutual benefits inherent in the US-China tech relationship.

Innovation and Dependency

The effectiveness of export controls has come into question following the release of DeepSeek-R1, a Chinese large language model rivaling leading US technologies. This development either points to the success of Chinese innovation independent of US technology or suggests circumvention of American restrictions, as indicated by a US House Select Committee report on Chinese purchases via intermediaries.

Despite ongoing efforts to limit China's technological ascent, these actions have not deterred its progress. China's tech sector continues to show strength, highlighted by a significant outperformance of Chinese tech stocks compared to the US, driven by domestic advancements in deep learning and AI infrastructure.

As the US and China navigate this complex landscape, the importance of critical minerals has come to the forefront. Both countries are engaged in securing essential supply chains, with China's recent export controls on rare earths posing new challenges to the US strategy.

Secretary Lutnick's comments about getting China "addicted" to the US tech stack have provoked backlash and prompted China to accelerate its self-sufficiency initiatives. This underscores the sensitivity of dependency perceptions within international tech relations.

The broader implications of these dynamics highlight a reorientation of global technology strategies, with the US aiming to expand AI technology influence while managing the geopolitical challenges of dependency and competition with China.

---
Read More USA Works News